Reading time: 3 minutes
Policy · Revelation
Episode #41
Reminder of the dilemma
A — Accept the authoritarian pact: first develop, then democratize.
B — Maintain full democracy, even at the cost of slowness.
If you chose A
This choice reveals the temptation of the historical shortcut: believe that the full belly naturally makes the free citizen. It's the Rwandan, Singaporean, Chinese bet — seductive on paper, but which assumes a virtuous leader where Africa has mostly known predatory autocrats.
If you have chosen B
This choice affirms that political dignity is not a luxury reserved for rich peoples. But it exposes a cruel risk: that democracy becomes an empty shell in which hungry people end up electing their own fossilists, for lack of concrete results.
This dilemma is the Gordian node of the continent. Since independence, Africa has fluctuated between two betrayed promises: that of authoritarian development, which has generated Mobutu, Bongo and decades of kleptocracy dressed in modernization; and that of imported democracy, which has often produced elections without electricity, parliaments without budget and alternations without transformation.
The Asian model fascinates because it has worked — Singapore, South Korea, Vietnam. But one conveniently forgets his failures: Myanmar, Cambodia, Marcos' Philippines. The decisive variable is never the regime itself, but the quality of the institutions, the rigour of justice, the ability of the state to discipline itself. This is precisely what Africa is struggling to build, whatever the system chosen.
Choosing option A is playing roulette with history hoping to fall on a Lee Kuan Yew rather than a Mugabe. Choosing option B means accepting that democratic construction is a marathon, not a sprint — But the runners must not starve on the way.
The truth, uncomfortable, is that this dilemma is wrong. Senegal has shown that justice can be reformed, the rule of law strengthened and infrastructure invested without sacrificing one another. But this requires political courage that neither the pressing autocrats nor the front democrats possess.
Baobab never chooses between its roots and its canopy. He knows that some feed the other, that invisible depth conditions the visible greatness. A country that amputates its democracy to develop its economy is a tree that cuts its roots to grow faster — It rises for a while, then collapses at the first storm.
To go further
Reform to ensure: democracy, rule of law and effective justice in Senegal
Senegal has a major political and legal tradition in Africa. However, this tradition does not exempt ...
The United States sick of its health system: Anatomy of a superpower unable to treat its population fairly
Imagine a country capable of sending probes to the edge of the solar system, mapping the human genome and...
Democracy, Development and Africa: Should we draw inspiration from the Asian model to break out of underdevelopment?
For more than half a century, Africa has sought its way between two aspirations often presented as a c...
Next dilemma Next Monday
